'Most Innovative Startup 2020' by RSA - Watch the video

Learn More

Things are getting serious for 101 EU data controllers sending data to the US – Max Schrems’ organization “NOYB” lodges complaints with various EU authorities

One month ago, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered its "Schrems II" ruling (16 July 2020, C-311/18), thereby declaring the EU-US Privacy Shield invalid. Although the CJEU found the standard contractual clauses (SCC) remain valid, it pointed out that the formal conclusion of the SCC alone may not be sufficient to safeguard data transfers to so-called “third countries” outside the EU, particularly the US. Rather, the data exporter and data importer must ensure that the data is granted the same protection in the third country as it is within the EU under the GDPR and the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.

Max Schrems, the defendant in the proceedings which formed the basis for the Schrems II judgment, directly responded to the judgment. On his not-for-profit organization’s (NOYB – European Center for Digital Rights) website, he provided sample inquiries for companies as well as data subjects, which they can send to data processors and data controllers. The templates are used to request information on how the respective companies secure the transfer of data to third countries following the judgement.

Now the organization has filed 101 complaints with the relevant supervisory authorities against EU controllers that use Google Analytics and Facebook Connect integrations on their webpages. The affected controllers include large international companies from various business sectors. The complaints are identical in content. NOYB argues that the use of the Google and Facebook services requires the transfer of personal data to the USA. The parties, however, failed to implement adequate safeguards when continuing to transfer data to the US. Based on these arguments, NOYB requests that the authorities fully investigate the complaint and immediately impose a ban or suspension of any data transfers from the data controllers to Google and Facebook in the US and order the return of such data to the EU or another country that provides adequate protection. In addition, the supervisory authorities shall impose fines on the data controller as well as Google and Facebook.

It remains to be seen how the supervisory authorities deal with the complaints. Given their individual responsibilities, there is no obligation for the various EU regulators to develop a coordinated consolidated approach. Instead, it is possible that there will be different reactions from the authorities in the individual proceedings: In their initial comments, the supervisory authorities had expressed very different views on the Schrems II judgment. While some authorities stated that a transfer to a third country based on SCC alone was considered inadmissible, others took a much less strict view. The varying opinions will probably also be reflected in the responses to the complaints.

In any case, the complaint procedures and the resulting reactions of the supervisory authorities may serve as a guideline for other controllers and processors as to which measures must be taken in future to lawfully transfer data to third countries, especially the US.

Share this

On-Demand Webinar

Navigating the Impact of “Schrems II” and Cross-Border Data Transfers

Register Now
Michael Morgan

Michael Morgan

CIPP/US, Partner, Global Privacy & Cybersecurity, McDermott Will & Emery

Srinivas Avasarala

Srinivas Avasarala

VP Product Management, Securiti

Our Videos

universal consent thumbnail View More

Universal Consent & Preference Management

Universal Consent & Preference Management

Learn More
cookie consent management video thumbnail View More

Cookie Consent Management

Automate and manage the entire consent life cycle with efficiency for various cookie compliance regulations around the world.

Learn More
data intelligence thumbnail View More

Sensitive Data Intelligence

Discover granular insights into all aspects of your privacy and security functions while reducing security risks and lowering the overall costs

Learn More
data mapping video thumbnail View More

Data Mapping Automation

Simplify gathering information, dynamically update your data catalog, and automate assessments and reports

Learn More
View More

An IT Leader’s Perspective on CCPA

Meet Brian Lillie, Former CPO at Equinix as he discusses the potential challenges of CCPA and how the PrivacyOps framework can be the key to unlocking compliance.

Learn More
Most Innovative Startup 2020 SECURITI.ai View More

RSA Innovation Sandbox 2020: Securiti

Watch the 3-minute pitch presented by Rehan Jalil on SECURITI.ai in the RSAC Sandbox Competition

Learn More