EDPB Opinions on UK Adequacy: Strong Alignment but Challenges Remain

Published April 23, 2021 / Updated November 6, 2024
Author

Maria Khan

Data Privacy Legal Manager at Securiti

FIP, CIPT, CIPM, CIPP/E

Listen to the content

On 19 February 2021, the European Commission published its draft UK adequacy decision that allowed for continued free flow of personal data from the EU into the UK. On 13 April 2021, the EDPB delivered Opinion 14/2021 for transfers of personal data under the GDPR and Opinion 15/2021 for transfers of personal data under the Law Enforcement Directive.

AREAS OF STRONG ALIGNMENT

The EDPB notes that there are many areas of convergence between UK and EU data protection frameworks such as the following:

  • Concepts of personal data, processing of personal data, and the data controller
  • Grounds for lawful and fair processing for legitimate purposes
  • Purpose limitation
  • Data quality and proportionality
  • Data retention, security, and confidentiality
  • Transparency
  • Special categories of data
  • Direct marketing
  • Automated decision-making and profiling

AREAS OF CONCERN / CHALLENGES

Despite the areas of convergence, there are certain aspects in the UK data protection framework that need to be closely monitored by the European Commission to ensure that the essentially equivalent level of protection is met.

Some of the aspects highlighted by the EDPB are as follows:

Immigration Exemption:

The immigration exemption in the UK data protection framework restricts data subjects’ rights to information, access, rectification, erasure, restriction of processing, and object to the extent that giving effect to these rights is likely to prejudice the maintenance of effective immigration control. It applies to controllers who process personal data for immigration control purposes or transfer data to controllers who are responsible for such processing. The EDPB notes that the exemption is broadly formulated and there is a lack of a legally binding instrument that clarifies its scope.

2. Restrictions on onward transfers:

There are certain aspects of the UK legislative framework concerning onward transfers that might undermine the level of protection of personal data transferred from the European Economic Area (EEA). In this regard, the EDPB recognizes the following challenges:

  • The first challenge relates to the recognition of third countries, international organizations, or territories as adequate recipients by the UK.
  • The second challenge relates to the upcoming review of the already existing adequacy decisions. This means that certain countries that benefited until now from an adequacy decision may no longer provide for an essentially equivalent level of protection taking into account the current EU legislation and recent case laws. However, the fact that the UK has already recognized those countries as providing for an adequate level of protection is a matter of consideration.
  • The third challenge relates to the onward transfer of personal data from the EEA to non-adequate countries based on transfer tools provided in Articles 46 and 47 of the UK GDPR.
  • The fourth challenge relates to international agreements concluded or to be concluded in the future by the UK and the possible direct access to EEA personal data by authorities from third countries to such agreements. The EDPB has strong concerns about the already concluded UK-US CLOUD Act Agreement that came into force in July 2020. The EDPB notes that it may affect the substantive and procedural conditions under which personal data held by data controllers or processors in the UK can be directly accessed by US authorities, thereby impacting the level of protection guaranteed under UK law.
  • The fifth challenge relates to the application of derogations for the transfers of personal data to a third country and the ICO’s interpretation of those derogations.
  • The sixth challenge relates to the absence of essentially equivalent protections provided under Article 48 of the GDPR in the UK legal framework.
3. Access and use of personal data transferred from the EU by public authorities in the UK:

In relation to the access of personal data by public authorities in the UK, the EDPB recommends the European Commission to assess the following aspects of the UK legal framework:

  • The possible use of consent in a law enforcement context
  • The day-to-day data collecting operations of law enforcement agencies such as the GCHQ and NCA and the legal framework applicable to them for the processing of personal data
  • The use of essential guarantees for national security purposes
  • The possible impact of restrictions in relation to the further use of the information collected for the law enforcement purposes
  • The legal basis of the use of personal data for purposes other than for law enforcement within the UK but the data was originally collected for the law enforcement purposes
  • Any international agreements that may affect the application of UK data protection law
  • The independence of the Surveillance Camera Commissioner, the Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material, and judicial commissioners who are not serving as judges.
  • The oversight mechanisms with regard to security certificates issued under the Data Protection Act 1998
  • Data subjects have the right to request the High Court to compel a controller to correct or delete their personal data without unnecessary delay.
  • The scope of exemptions for national security purposes
4. Investigatory powers exercised in the context of national security:

The Investigatory Powers Act 2016 sets out the extent to which certain investigatory powers may be used to interfere with privacy. The EDPB notes the following points of attention in relation to the scope of the application of the IPA 2016:

  • The first point of attention relates to intentionally broad definitions of telecommunications operators, telecommunications service, and telecommunications system, among other similar terms. The EDPB recommends the European Commission assess these definitions keeping in consideration the proportionality of the interception measures.
  • The second point of attention is the lack of clarity on whether or not data from establishments of telecommunications operators outside the UK is covered within the broad definition of “telecommunications operators”, to the extent that data of EEA data subjects are concerned.
  • The third point of attention concerns the scenarios for which lawful interceptions and bulk acquisition of communications data is possible without the approval of  the Investigatory Powers Commissioner or the judicial commissioners.
5. Bulk interception of data:

The EDPB notes that there is a need for the assessment of bulk interceptions, in particular, the selection and application of selectors in the context of bulk interception procedures and whether or not safeguards are in place to protect the fundamental rights of individuals whose data are intercepted in this context.

6. Further use of the information collected for national security purposes and overseas disclosure:

The application of national security exemption provided under the UK law may compromise the principles of purpose limitation, necessity and proportionality, and data subjects’ rights in the third country of destination. Therefore, the EDPB recommends the European Commission to examine the overall safeguards provided under the UK legal framework when it comes to overseas disclosures, in light of the application of national security exemption.

What is Next?

The European Commission will now seek approval on the UK adequacy decision from the representatives of each member state. Following that, it will adopt a final decision regarding the UK adequacy. The UK is likely to be approved as an adequate country. However, the fact that the EDPB highlighted many areas of concern in the UK legal framework reflects an extremely cautious and objective approach towards cross-border data transfers. This approach indicates that the UK adequacy decision will be subject to regular reviews and monitoring by the European Commission.

Analyze this article with AI

Prompts open in third-party AI tools.
Join Our Newsletter

Get all the latest information, law updates and more delivered to your inbox



More Stories that May Interest You
Videos
View More
Rehan Jalil, Veeam on Agent Commander : theCUBE + NYSE Wired: Cyber Security Leaders
Following Veeam’s acquisition of Securiti, the launch of Agent Commander marks an important step toward helping enterprises adopt AI agents with greater confidence. In...
View More
Mitigating OWASP Top 10 for LLM Applications 2025
Generative AI (GenAI) has transformed how enterprises operate, scale, and grow. There’s an AI application for every purpose, from increasing employee productivity to streamlining...
View More
Top 6 DSPM Use Cases
With the advent of Generative AI (GenAI), data has become more dynamic. New data is generated faster than ever, transmitted to various systems, applications,...
View More
Colorado Privacy Act (CPA)
What is the Colorado Privacy Act? The CPA is a comprehensive privacy law signed on July 7, 2021. It established new standards for personal...
View More
Securiti for Copilot in SaaS
Accelerate Copilot Adoption Securely & Confidently Organizations are eager to adopt Microsoft 365 Copilot for increased productivity and efficiency. However, security concerns like data...
View More
Top 10 Considerations for Safely Using Unstructured Data with GenAI
A staggering 90% of an organization's data is unstructured. This data is rapidly being used to fuel GenAI applications like chatbots and AI search....
View More
Gencore AI: Building Safe, Enterprise-grade AI Systems in Minutes
As enterprises adopt generative AI, data and AI teams face numerous hurdles: securely connecting unstructured and structured data sources, maintaining proper controls and governance,...
View More
Navigating CPRA: Key Insights for Businesses
What is CPRA? The California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) is California's state legislation aimed at protecting residents' digital privacy. It became effective on January...
View More
Navigating the Shift: Transitioning to PCI DSS v4.0
What is PCI DSS? PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard) is a set of security standards to ensure safe processing, storage, and...
View More
Securing Data+AI : Playbook for Trust, Risk, and Security Management (TRiSM)
AI's growing security risks have 48% of global CISOs alarmed. Join this keynote to learn about a practical playbook for enabling AI Trust, Risk,...

Spotlight Talks

Spotlight 00:00
AI Agents Unleashed? The Future of Identity & Data Access Security
Watch Now View
Spotlight 00:00
IDC Research: Why Data, AI, Identity and Access Security Must Come Together
Watch Now View
Spotlight 59:11
Data Controls for AI: Findings from the 2026 GigaOm DSPM Research
Watch Now View
Spotlight 1:02:06
Consent by proxy: When AI agents start deciding for us
Watch Now View
Spotlight 1:00:41
Future-Proofing for the Privacy Professional
Watch Now View
Spotlight 50:52
From Data to Deployment: Safeguarding Enterprise AI with Security and Governance
Watch Now View
Spotlight 11:29
Not Hype — Dye & Durham’s Analytics Head Shows What AI at Work Really Looks Like
Not Hype — Dye & Durham’s Analytics Head Shows What AI at Work Really Looks Like
Watch Now View
Spotlight 11:18
Rewiring Real Estate Finance — How Walker & Dunlop Is Giving Its $135B Portfolio a Data-First Refresh
Watch Now View
Spotlight
Choosing the Right DSPM: An Industry Analyst’s Perspective
Watch Now View
Spotlight 13:38
Accelerating Miracles — How Sanofi is Embedding AI to Significantly Reduce Drug Development Timelines
Sanofi Thumbnail
Watch Now View
Latest
KSA PDPL in 2026 View More
KSA PDPL in 2026: What Organizations Need to Know Now
KSA's Personal Data Protection Law (PDPL) has been fully enforceable since 14th September 2024. Over the past two years, organizations have been navigating overlapping...
EU Digital Sovereignty View More
EU Digital Sovereignty is Moving from Policy to Procurement: What Organizations Need to Know
Digital sovereignty in Europe is moving from policy ambition toward something much more concrete: a framework that can determine how cloud services are assessed,...
View More
What Is Unstructured Data Discovery? A Practical Guide
Unstructured data discovery finds sensitive data in files, chats, and cloud storage. Securiti explains how it works, common challenges, and best practices.
Data Anonymization View More
What Is Data Anonymization
What is data anonymization? Securiti’s latest blog explains how it works, key techniques, and how it differs from pseudonymization. Read to learn more.
Saudi PDPL Compliance Toolkit View More
Saudi PDPL Compliance Toolkit
Turn Saudi PDPL requirements into action with practical checklists, a maturity self-assessment, and a 90-day plan for privacy and compliance leaders.
From Compliance to Continuous Assurance View More
From Compliance to Continuous Assurance: The Next Era of Saudi Data Protection
PDPL compliance didn’t end with the deadline. Learn how to comply with SDAIA enforcement requirements, govern cross-border transfers, and prepare your data for AI.
Data Minimization, Data Minimization for AI, Safe AI, AI Readiness, ROT Data, AI Governance, Data Governance, Data and AI Security, AI Risk Management, Sensitive Data View More
Minimize Before You Scale
Discover why redundant, obsolete, and trivial (ROT) data raises AI-era risks and how to minimize them. Explore practical fixes and business outcomes.
The PDPL Operational Lifecycle View More
The PDPL Operational Lifecycle
Find it. Fix it. Prove it. Repeat. Explore the 10-stage PDPL operational lifecycle, key deadlines, and the evidence regulators expect.
View More
Take the Data Risk Out of AI
Learn how to prepare enterprise data for safe Gemini Enterprise adoption with upstream governance, sensitive data discovery, and pre-index policy controls.
View More
Navigating HITRUST: A Guide to Certification
Securiti's eBook is a practical guide to HITRUST certification, covering everything from choosing i1 vs r2 and scope systems to managing CAPs & planning...
What's
New